In 2011, the Advocacy Training Council (ATC) published Raising the Bar which was the result of a 20-month research project into the type of training that might be appropriate for advocates working with children and vulnerable witnesses. The three virtues espoused by the report still hold true:
“First, it should at all times be sensitive and understanding with regard to the needs and vulnerabilities of the person concerned. Second, it should uphold the requirement rigorously to examine the evidence and fulfil the barrister’s duty both to court and client. Third, it should seek to elicit ‘Best Evidence’”.
The ICCA’s national programme was originally developed by members of a pan-profession working group, led by HHJ Rook QC, in response to the Government’s September 2014 Commitment to Victims paper.
In October 2018, the MOJ issued a new Victims Strategy in which they commended the profession for exceeding the government’s 2014 manifesto commitment. They described the training as ‘both recognised and highly valued by relevant experts who work to support victims’ rights and with organisations such as the NSPCC’.
The profession can take heart from the October 2018 Judicial Perceptions report on the quality of criminal advocacy which stated that:
‘One area of practice that is recognised to be largely improving, is advocates’ ability to deal with young and vulnerable witnesses. The training provided to advocates about vulnerable witnesses and defendants, and the adaptations to court practice for vulnerable court users, now more routinely embedded in court procedures, are thought to have benefitted advocates’.
Many experts were involved in the creation of this course and leading judges, practitioners and academics continue to support and advise on its iterative development. The 20 Principles were created by reference to original, practice-led guidance from HHJ Sally Cahill QC and they were refined and endorsed by leading academics, Professor Michael Lamb and Professor Jacqueline Wheatcroft. They have been updated taking account of lessons learnt and contain clearer explanations and rationale.
The A&V course was designed to ensure that all advocates, when dealing with children vulnerable witnesses, understand the key principles behind the approach to, and questioning of, vulnerable people in the justice system, irrespective of the nature of the allegation, or the jurisdiction in which the advocate appears. The training is the first step in adjusting the ‘advocacy approach’ to cases such as these. Continual professional development in this area is strongly recommended.
At the forefront of every advocate’s practice should be an awareness and understanding of current law and procedure. Of paramount importance in relation to children and vulnerable witnesses and defendants is familiarity with the current Criminal Practice Directions governing matters such as special measures, intermediaries, s.28 hearings and Ground Rules Hearings. This knowledge base should be the starting point when preparing cases of this nature. The most recent consolidated criminal practice direction can be found here.
The problems caused by lengthy, repetitive, intimidating and confusing questioning of vulnerable witnesses and defendants is now widely known. As a result of the traditional form and content of questioning, those with vulnerabilities involved in the process have reported feeling alienated and in some cases violated.
It is recognised that our adversarial system must permit challenge of crucial evidence. It should not encroach on the rights of a defendant to challenge the evidence against him or her in a fair and appropriate way. The skill is in allowing this to be done without exploiting or taking unfair advantage of a child or a person with a vulnerability.
The reliance upon a Ground Rules Hearing has proved to have been an effective procedural step as a result of which, special measures and intermediary and expert interventions have been carefully and creatively used to ascertain the best way for the vulnerable individual to effectively participate in the trial process.
The training has been designed to be delivered in a cascaded way on three levels.
Lead Facilitators are at the vanguard of the national training programme. There are around 65 Lead Facilitators who trained in the early phase of the course and went on to train over 250 Facilitators. Between them they have delivered training to over 3,000 members of the Bar, Crown Prosecutors and Solicitors. Read more
Facilitators are the key to the success of the national training programme and have set the standard for excellence and ability to adapt to the changing landscape of questioning the vulnerable.
Delegates are being trained across the country via the Inns and Circuits and by individual sets of Chambers, the CPS, SAHCA and the Law Society.
A Bridging Course has been developed to allow for a small band of talented delegates to fast-track to become a Facilitator.Coming soon...